Willing v. Willfulness


              Dryden, DiGiuseppe, and Neenan (2003) outlined two fundamental capacities: The first is a tendency to “transform” “desires into absolute musts” especially “when those desires are strong (Ellis, 1976)” (p. 5) The seond has to do with human volition. We also as a species have the power to “identify, challenge and change” our thinking and feeling in keeping with our goals. (Ibid, p. 6)

               The first capacity which involves stirring up your anger and frustration when your wants are frustrated in some way. This capacity falls into the two broad categories: Ego Disturbances and Discomfort Disturbances. (Dryden, DiGiuseppe, & Neenan, 2003, p. 6) Ego Disturbances involve all circumstances that threaten self-esteem in some way. Discomfort Disturbances involve all circumstances that threaten one’s comfort in any way.

               Ultimately, a big part of increasing ones ability to tolerate distress involves a commitment to reality including the reality of being less than God and less than living in the lap of luxury and floating to heaven on flowery beds of ease.

               I particularly like how Linehan (1993) puts in in her book Cognitive Behavioral Therapy of Borderline Personality Disorder. She wrote that the specific distress tolerance skills taught in Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT) are informed by two types of acceptance and Gerald May’s (1992) concept of willingness versus willfulness.

               The first type of acceptance involves accepting myself as I am. The other involves accepting my life experience as it is. Both forms of acceptance involve approaching life from a willing versus a willful stance as originally written about by Gerald May (1982) in Will and Spirit. Linehan (1993a) wrote of the different between willing and willful attitudes as follows:

The essential tension is between responding to a situation in terms of what the situation needs (willingness) and responding in a way that resists what a situation needs or responding in terms of one’s own needs rather than those of the situation (willfulness). Thus, willfulness encompasses both trying to “fix” the situation and sitting passively on one’s hands, refusing to response at all. (p. 39)  

        Accepting reality on its own terms marks a decided shift from willful, largely maladaptive thought, feeling and behavior to willing, largely adaptive thought, feeling and behavior.

References

Dryden, W., DiGiuseppe, R., & Neenan, M. (2003). A primer on rational emotive behavior therapy. Champaign, IL: Research Press.

Linehan, M. M. (1993). Cognitive behavioral treatment of borderline personality disorder. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

Linehan, M. M. (1993a). Skills training manual for treating borderline personality disorder. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

May, G. G. (1982). Will and spirit. New York: HarperCollins e-books.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Freud on the Dynamics of Transference

Freud on the Dynamics of Transference I decided to read Freud's 1912 "Dynamics of Transference" after reading the following statement in Cozolino's "The Neuroscience of Psychotherapy" where he talked about the projective hypothesis. There Cozolino wrote: "Despite a conscious awareness that something may be wrong, the hidden layers of neural  processing continue to organize the world based on the prior experiences that shaped them. As we  will see in later chapters, the neural circuitry involved with fear has a tenacious memory and can  invisibly influence conscious awareness for a lifetime. Part of psychodynamic therapy is an  exploration and uncovering of this unconscious organization of experience. Freud’s projective  hypothesis described the process by which our brains create and organize the world around us.  As  the clarity of a situation decreases, the brain naturally generates structure and projects it onto the  world. The way we organize a...
Read more

Why Does Mindfulness Reduce Calm Stress, Improve Your Mood, and Promote Better Health?

Image
Mindfulness reduces stress and improves health. This is a robust scientific finding supported by many recent scientific experimental research. If you want to benefit from this, you can start being mindful right now.            1.  Pay attention on purpose to your thoughts and feelings. You don't have to close your eyes but that may help. You can also add some soothing music.            2.  In addition to paying attention to your thoughts and feelings you can also purposely slow and deepen your breathing.           3.  In paying attention on purpose (called monitoring) you will also purposely ACCEPT Your thoughts and feelings even if you don't agree or like them.           R ecently published scientific research highlighted this acceptance component of mindfulness. Using a dismantling technique in a randomized and controlled test of three different gr...
Read more
 Dr. Jim reads About Bowen's Differentiation of Self, Part 1                In 1975 Wilson wrote about three key properties of social organization: c ohesiveness, altruism, and c ooperativeness. In the animal kingdom only four groups of animals have been able to significantly develop these properties: (1) colonial invertebrates—coral/the Portuguese man-of-war; (2) social insects (ants, termites, certain wasps and bees), (3) nonhuman mammals (particularly the elephants, chimpanzees, and African wild dogs), and (4) humans. It's important to recognize that high levels of social integration are not inherently "good" for the adaptiveness of a species.                The key to the "level of complexity" of our social organization involves our capacity for abstraction in the service of win-win social groupings and self-government. This capacity enables us to "establish long-remembered contracts and...
Read more